We’ve been writing extensively about the future role of 5G and how 3.5GHz spectrum feeds into that role. Unfortunately for some operators, 5G is just a pipe dream – particularly in a place like South Africa. Here, the government has not issued or auctioned off any spectrum for the last 14 years. In fact, South Africa has one of the lowest spectrum allocations of all markets globally. This should mean that the market has one of the lowest returns of all, as the operators all struggle to provide capacity for consumers. But this is where it gets interesting – the opposite has happened. The operators have merely kept data pricing at the highest level possible to limit capacity issues. Now the blame game begins. Whilst the government and the industry try blame each other, investors in Vodacom are likely to suffer the most (LINK). Vodafone, being the majority shareholder, should take note. In fact, we think Vodafone should consider whether spinning off Vodacom to its shareholders may make sense to give them the choice as to whether they should continue owning the asset.
South Africa has the highest data pricing across 30 markets that we cover. To give an example: An iPhone XR package with 1.2GB of data costs $120/month on Vodacom. The same phone, with 15GB of data (and unlimited voice/SMS) in the UK costs US$67/month on Vodafone’s network. Given wealth differentials between the two markets, this is not sustainable.
By keeping prices high, the operators can manage network stress, instead of having to invest more aggressively to increase capacity. We estimate that Vodacom’s network is less constrained than the global average which is why it has not invested significantly to offset spectrum shortages and therefore been able to report super-normal returns. For investors this has been a great situation over the last decade. But there are two issues which makes us more cautious going forward:
- Regulatory/government action heating up: Fuelled by a consumer campaign (#datamustfall), the regulator has instigated a review of data prices. The Competition Commission recently published its findings which were damning for the industry (HERE). And finally, the President has been highlighting data tariffs as a key barrier to economic growth and is looking to issue spectrum in the next few months. All these issues suggest Vodacom (and MTN) will have to act to show willing, otherwise repercussions will intensify; and
- Competition is now starting to get its act together: One of the reasons tariffs have remained high is that there hasn’t been a well-funded operator to challenge the dominance of MTN and Vodacom. Enter Telkom with prices 80% lower than Vodacom which is beginning to gain traction. Although Vodacom has >4x the number of subscribers, Telkom carries more traffic. Vodacom is having to react.
High returns are a good thing, if they can be sustained. Unfortunately for Vodacom we don’t think they will be. With regulation and competition beginning to bite, Vodacom is being pushed into a corner. It’s forced them to launch aggressive promotions which were costly (HERE). As the pressure intensifies, expect them to make more mistakes. It’s a journey we wouldn’t recommend being part of. If you want access to African growth potential at reasonable multiples, MTN has great assets across Sub-Saharan Africa (HERE), along with Airtel Africa (HERE). But for Vodacom whose value is predominantly exposed to a deteriorating market outlook in SA, we would stay away.
Full 12-month historical recommendation changes are available on request
Reports produced by New Street Research LLP. 52 Cornhill, London EC3V 3PD Tel: +44 20 7375 9111.
New Street Research LLP is authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority and is registered in the United States with the Securities and Exchange Commission as a foreign investment adviser.
Regulatory Disclosures: This research is directed only at persons classified as Professional Clients under the rules of the Financial Conduct Authority (‘FCA’), and must not be re-distributed to Retail Clients as defined in the rules of the FCA.
This research is for our clients only. It is based on current public information which we consider reliable, but we do not represent that it is accurate or complete, and it should not be relied on as such. We seek to update our research as appropriate, but various regulations may prevent us from doing so. Most of our reports are published at irregular intervals as appropriate in the analyst's judgment. This research is not an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security in any jurisdiction where such an offer or solicitation would be illegal. It does not constitute a personal recommendation or take into account the particular investment objectives, financial situations, or needs of individual clients.
All our research reports are disseminated and available to all clients simultaneously through electronic publication to our website.
New Street Research LLC is neither a registered investment advisor nor a broker/dealer. Subscribers and/or readers are advised that the information contained in this report is not to be construed or relied upon as investment, tax planning, accounting and/or legal advice, nor is it to be construed in any way as a recommendation to buy or sell any security or any other form of investment. All opinions, analyses and information contained herein is based upon sources believed to be reliable and is written in good faith, but no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, is made herein concerning any investment, tax, accounting and/or legal matter or the accuracy, completeness, correctness, timeliness and/or appropriateness of any of the information contained herein. Subscribers and/or readers are further advised that the Company does not necessarily update the information and/or opinions set forth in this and/or any subsequent version of this report. Readers are urged to consult with their own independent professional advisors with respect to any matter herein. All information contained herein and/or this website should be independently verified.
All research is issued under the regulatory oversight of New Street Research LLP.
© Copyright 2021 New Street Research LLP
No part of this material may be copied, photocopied or duplicated in any form by any means or redistributed without the prior written consent of New Street Research LLP.